Supernatural Brownies still Supernatural after 5 years in drawer

I had offered to bring a dessert to a friend’s house this weekend (she was making dinner) and needed something that was both adult and kid friendly.  In my drawer of recipes I rediscovered this one for “Supernatural Brownies” clipped from the New York Times in 2007.  I  made them many times in 2007 and then kind of forgot about them (either that or I’ve been in a chocolate coma and just woke up in 2012).  Other than the fact that they’re not dairy-free (my friend Meredith can’t eat dairy–and I totally forgot that too) they seemed perfect.

To avoid being a total dessert jerk I brought Meredith some Mango Gelato from Ed’s Real Scoop (I know a pretty feeble gesture) while the rest of us enjoyed these brownies which turned out as moist, chewy and chocolatey as I remembered them.  So I thought I would share the recipe or rekindle your memories of it if you too had once loved–and lost– it.

This recipe originally come from a piece in the New York Time by Julia Moskin  which included 3 brownie recipes (French Chocolate Brownies and New Classic Brownies).  I stopped trying alternate recipes after I tried the Supernatural recipe as it seemed there was no point in exploring further.

This is the NYT’s recipe, as adapted from “Chocolate: From Simple Cookies to Extravagant Showstoppers,” by Nick Malgieri (Morrow Cookbooks, 1998).

I got chocolate on the dish. Messy picture. Sorry!

1. You need to butter a 9 x 13 ” pan and then line the bottom with parchment, and butter that.  Now preheat the oven to 350 °F.

2. In a double boiler or a stainless steel bowl set over a wide pot, melt 8 oz bittersweet chocolate with 2 sticks of unsalted butter.  You can give it a stir once in a while. then  when melted and combined set aside to cool slightly.  (you can melt theses  in the microwave as well)

3. Now you’re going to put your eggs in a large bowl and whisk them lightly with a hand blender and then add in 1 cup white sugar, 1 cup brown sugar, 1/4 tsp salt and 2 tsp vanilla.

4. Pour the chocolate mixture into the egg batter and whisk the two until combined.

Brownie worlds collide.

5. Now add 1 cup all-purpose flour and gently fold it in with a spatula until just combined.  Don’t over mix.

6. Pour the batter into the greased dish and bake for about 35-40 minutes.  Until the top is just cracking and becoming glossy.   Remove and allow to cool before slicing.

I prefer to cut the pieces smaller as they are very rich.  And it sounds better to allow your self two rather than one, or a dozen rather than just six. (Once you eat more than 6 you should consider it a meal.)

The final brownies will be shiny and cracking on top with a rich, mist and chewy middle.

And here is your shopping list of ingredients:

2 sticks (16 tablespoons) butter, plus extra for greasing pan
8 ounces bittersweet chocolate
4 eggs
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 cup dark brown sugar
1 cup granulated sugar
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
1 cup flour

Other than the baking and cooling, preparing this is fast and simple.  A good one for potlucks, birthday parties or Apocalypse planning sessions.


Filed under All Recipes, Cookbooks, Magazines (+recipes from), Ruminations on the Edible

10 responses to “Supernatural Brownies still Supernatural after 5 years in drawer

  1. Cindy

    Who needs coffee in the morning when you can read and see, preferably EAT Supernatural Brownies. Oh, wait. With the coffee! That’s gotta put a zip in your step.
    Sue, can you tell me where you get the wonderful Vanilla Bean Paste? I practically eat that stuff right out of the jar. And put it in my milk as I heat it up and froth it for my coffee. I end up at Williams Sonoma, but there has to be somewhere closer to Yonge and Lawrence/Eglinton/St.Clair.
    Thanks for your lovely blog. It always puts a smile on my face.

  2. Hello Cindy! OMG I never even thought of putting it in my milk. How much time have I wasted? The horror!

    I also have gotten it at William Sonoma but the one I have is actually from Barabara across the street who didn’t think she’s use it all. Would it be easy enough to go across to Lawrence and DonMills to McKewans on the way home one day (do you drive?)
    I imagine they would have it. Also am thinking of All the Best Fine Foods at Yonge and Summerhill (and you can pop into that amazing LCBO!)

    Either or those work?

  3. The thought of baking brownies last night was immediately imbedded in my mind as soon as I read this post. I picked up a few of the ingredients that I was missing and went straight home after work to bake them. The recipe does not fail! These were delicious! And I even used a combination of semi-sweet choc and bittersweet, in fact, most was semi-sweet (5 1/2 oz.) They truly were moist on the inside and shiny and crisp on the top. Beautiful! I had to take most into work today to avoid eating the entire tray. Thanks for sharing!

  4. This sounds like the perfect brownie recipe that I need to make to reward myself for trying desperately to avoid getting fat this winter. It’s practically spring- I deserve a little congratulatory square.

    Thanks for posting- I was just wondering if vanilla extract will work the same?

  5. I think vanilla extract is in the original recipe, I actually had this on hand and had run out of vanilla extract!

    They are good Johanne–but as Michelle found–you can’t eat one square!
    They’re quite simple too.

  6. Pingback: Toast Post: Tomme de Savoie (can keep you skinny) | cheese and toast

  7. Pingback: Happy Easter! « Fashion in Motion

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s